The Sietch Blog

Feb 05
Us Vs. Them

Written by Rt

Many here wish we would emulate Germany, and their progress in RE is certainly worthy of emulation. But let’s understand the differences between us before we make rash judgements. The point I am going to try to make here is the ability to “turn on a dime”.

When it comes to percentages size does matter. I found this interesting reading about us and them (and here and here). Doing some very rough estimating we are about 25 times their land size, over 3 times the number of people, and over 4 times the GDP. This means not only are comparisons difficult to make but the the old analogy of “the bigger the ship the harder to turn” applies as well. That said it also means we have more resources to throw at the problem. In reality it means we have more vested interests to battle.

Another large difference is the amount of energy resources available. We have over 30 times the amount of coal, over 20 times the amount of natural gas, and over 50 times the amount of oil. It shouldn’t be surprising that we use this stuff, we have it! It’s one of the reasons we dominated the 20th century. I make no apologies for our use of natural resources. We could have done it better but hindsight is always best. Now our knowlege of the effects is better. Now the technology for the production of RE has advanced. So now it’s time to move on.

I admire Germany for many reasons (some day I would like to taste their beer :). I am especially jealous of their current account (an accounting term – loosely and overly simplified, your financial health) – they are $120 billion to the good and we are $821 billion to the bad. Granted, the world expects us to help keep everyone well but really.

I have said all of this not in the US vs. Germany context. These are just examples. This is to, hopefully, give you insight as to the complexities of the task at hand. If you are trying to proselytize someone to the RE way of thinking try to understand their point of view. There are factors, like economics, that other people consider. Indeed, I believe the economic factors in Germany make a much stronger case for RE than here.

When you speak, try to be understanding of the “them’s” opinion. Use that knowlege to provide rational, detailed arguments against their points. An argument between two people parroting dogma is a waste of time. Accept progress and withstand defeat. RE will stand on it’s own merits.